Cervical cancer in woman, 23, went undiagnosed after GP failed in duty of care

Amy Russell, of Manchester, brought a claim against her GP after she discovered two years later that she had cancer. However by this time the disease was much more advanced and meant extensive surgery.

Amy first went to her GP when she was concerned about some unusual bleeding she was experiencing between her periods and after having sex.  Her GP carried out a smear test. 

However, as Amy was only 23 at the time she was too young to be part of the national cervical cancer screening programme which starts when a woman is 25.

As a result, Amy’s cervical smear sample was destroyed without being looked at.  Somewhat surprisingly, this is in line with guidelines.  However, Amy’s GP had a responsibility to tell her the smear test had not been analysed, but didn’t.

Distressingly, if the sample had been analysed it would have shown early cancer cell changes and allowed Amy to undergo non-invasive and entirely curative treatment. 

Instead, Amy’s cervical cancer was only diagnosed when she was 25 and could be part of the national screening programme.  As a result of this delay, the cancer was more advanced and Amy had to undergo more extensive surgery which has impacted her day to day life.

Amy instructed Leigh Day clinical negligence partner Kirsten Wall and Amy’s GP admitted she had failed in the duty of care she owed to Amy.

The claim was settled for a five-figure sum.

Kirsten Wall said:

“Amy was aware from celebrities such as Jade Goody that, although rare, cervical cancer can affect young women and felt she was doing the sensible thing by seeking the advice of her GP. As a result of the GP’s failings, Amy suffered needlessly and had her concerns been followed through, her cervical cancer would have been discovered much sooner and the treatment would have been much less invasive.

“I would encourage all women to trust their instincts and follow up on any medical concerns they have.”

Amy Russell said:

“My experience shows that women should trust their own judgement and if their concerns are not taken seriously by a doctor, always insist on a second opinion. Cervical cancer can prove fatal and thankfully mine was caught in time. However, if my GP had followed through on my concerns, I would not have been through the trauma of discovering that my cancer had advanced and then had to have extensive surgery.”